POLYGON MODELING VS SPLINE: WHAT’S THE DIFFERENCE?

Polygon modeling: 3D render of a staircase with a row of wall lights along a white wall

Polygon modeling and spline modeling are two most commonly used approaches to creating 3D objects. Both options are capable of producing high-quality three-dimensional models, but what are the differences between them? As a 3D modeling company, UFO 3D wants its clients to understand the process of making digital items better. But first, some trivia.

First, it’s important to understand that 3D models are created as surfaces first, and are more about numbers rather than artistry. They can be created automatically, by scanning real objects with a 3D scanner or letting the computer to turn a 2D image into a 3D object (the CAD method), or manually. Polygon modeling is one way to create a three-dimensional item non-automatically, which consists of connecting points in space called vertices into a 2D surface and then combining and moving said surfaces to form a “shell”. Spline (or NURBS) modeling creates contours of objects with mathematically precise and complex curves, similarly to pitching pegs for a tent, and then forming surfaces around them. And finally, there is 3D sculpting – a new method of creating three-dimensional objects, which involves molding solid digital geometric shapes into items, like clay.

After the model is made using 3D modeling software, it can be used in a variety of ways: for video game creation, CGI movie production, 3D printing or just to visualize ideas. When 3D objects are used in motion, their texture quality has to be lower to reduce CPU memory usage. In static product rendering, the quality will be at its best. The key difference between polygon and spline modeling is that the former is used in video game creation due to its flexibility and latter is used in movies, architecture and product design due to level of detail that can be achieved with it. Now, with explanation of 3D modeling essentials and differences between means of doing it out of the way, let’s get to pros and cons of each method.

Polygon Modeling

polygonal 3d modeling
The highlighted object on the left is a polygon model. Those fine lines are individual faces, and that’s how many polygon modeling needs before even this simple angled shape looks smooth.

Cons:

  • Detailed surfaces can be achieved only with thousands of polygons
  • Impossible to use Paint FX with individual polygons

Pros:

  • Easy to use, move around and combine
  • Polygons technically have infinite sides, so it’s possible to make surfaces of any size
  • Comes with texture maps, allowing easier editing
  • A lot of polygons can be modeled as a single surface

Spline Modeling

spline 3d modeling
Same shape, but now the spline version on the right is selected. It gets by with a handful of lines because the curves themselves describe the surface.

Cons:

  • Meshes only have four sides to work with
  • Surfaces are impossible to attach
  • Doesn’t have a texture map

Pros:

  • Resulting models are smoother than polygon modeling analogues
  • Can be used in conjunction with Paint FX
  • Takes up less data space
  • Easier to translate to different programs
  • Can be used to create “patches” for models, resulting in more organic, detailed and realistic-looking objects

Here is a demonstration of how a spline base is turned into a polygonal model.

spline demo
Early stage of a table. The top is still a thin spline profile, and the purple curves trace the carved detail under it.
spline 3d model
Next the profile becomes real geometry. See how heavy the white polygon mesh of the tabletop gets compared with the single curve it came from?
rendered 3d model
The finished table in a plain grey render. Soft edges, clean apron, and no sign that it began as a few spline curves.

We hope that this explanation was illuminating. This wasn’t a “polygon modeling/spline modeling is best” piece – what is good for you depends on what is your company producing. Since our specialty is 3D product visualization, we would gladly provide high-quality promotional materials for your products. Sell your merchandise using photorealistic 3D images today with our professional 3D product modeling company!

3D product modelingOne accurate model, and every image after it costs a fractionWe build it from CAD, drawings or photos at 20 USD an hour. A typical product comes to about 200 USD, and the file is yours.3D modeling services
Wireframe of a car interior 3D model with the seats and dashboard mesh visible

Which programs favour which method is part of our 3D modeling programs comparison. Both methods belong to the same workflow, described from start to finish in what is 3D modeling.

Frequently asked questions

Catherine Paul
Content Writer, Editor

Catherine is a content writer and editor. In her articles, she explains how CGI is transforming the world of architecture and design. Outside of office, she enjoys yoga, travelling, and watching horrors.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related articles